Moderators: Minimalist, MichelleH
circumspice wrote:@shawomet: Thanks for all the links!
shawomet wrote:Minimalist wrote:I would like to see a peer reviewed paper on these alleged Holocene Start Impacts.
And then I would like to see a review of that paper!
This is just a summary of such a paper, so you would need to reference the original article. This may have already been posted to archaeologica.org, I'm not certain. At any rate, you can dig deeper from here. This is just the most recent study in favor of the impact hypothesis.
https://phys.org/news/2017-03-discovery ... eople.html
Well, actually, the phys.org article did provide a link to the original paper:
https://www.nature.com/articles/srep44031
And supplementary information:
https://www.nature.com/article-assets/n ... 031-s1.pdf
Minimalist wrote:I guess I was not clear enough. I have searched a number of times for the phrase "Holocene Start Impacts" and the replies usually come back to some website that E.P. is deeply involved with.
circumspice wrote:@E.P.
I'm curious... Why have you chosen this forum as a repository for your research?
Why haven't you started your own forum & posted that vast amount of data there?
Wouldn't it make more sense to post on a forum dedicated to impacts?
Wouldn't a forum dedicated exclusively to impacts attract like minded researchers & establish a public dialog?
This is an archaeological forum, your research is only tangentially related to the subject of archaeology...
Tiompan wrote:E.P. Grondine wrote:I think we will not have really firm dates for Gobekli Tepe until nearby pristine geological cores are drilled,
their phytolith sequences mapped, and radio carbon measurements made in them.
I think your understanding of the radio carbon dating of ancient monuments is at about the same level as your understanding of genetics or astronomy .
Geological cores will tell you nothing about the date when the monument was built . Do you have any idea at all about phytoliths and the problems related to radio carbon dating them ?
By the way, that was rhetorical question .
"I have yet to read you state anywhere that they occurred."
Why does it have take so many repeats of quite simple comments before they sink in ?
For the umpteenth time."Read what I have said about these events and if you can find anything that is in error provide the quote ."
Minimalist wrote:E.P.
That's YOUR video. You are a lone voice shouting that an impact event started the Holocene. Why is it that no one else is persuaded?
Tiompan wrote:EP , yet again you fail to supply a quote that would highlight any error explicit or otherwise .
When you make one of your frequent errors I quote it, then refute it .
Are you now suggesting that your misunderstandings about archaeoastromomy or astronomy were not actually yours , but came from elsewhere ?
E.P. Grondine wrote:If you bothers to notice, the alignments were to Comet Giacobini Zimmer.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 3 guests